THE TRUSTED, WELCOMING, ETHICAL LAW FIRM YOU NEED

Fault vs. no-fault: How Kentucky handles car accidents

On Behalf of | Jun 30, 2025 | Motor Vehicle Accidents |

When someone hits you in a crash, your first thought might be to assign blame, especially if the other driver was reckless, distracted or clearly at fault. But in Kentucky, the law does not always begin with fault  – it starts with your own insurance, which usually covers certain costs first, even when you did nothing wrong. That’s because Kentucky uses a no-fault system by default. 

Still, fault doesn’t stay out of the picture for long. Once your injuries hit a certain point, everything shifts – and that’s when fault starts to matter. To see where fault fits in clearly, you first need to understand how no-fault coverage actually works.

No-fault coverage pays first through your own insurance

Kentucky law requires most drivers to carry personal injury protection (PIP). If a crash injures you, your own insurance pays up to $10,000 for medical bills, lost wages and out-of-pocket costs, regardless of who caused the wreck. You don’t need to file a lawsuit or prove fault to unlock this coverage. The system aims to get you treated quickly and help you avoid drawn-out litigation over minor injuries.

Fault becomes relevant when your injuries are serious

No-fault coverage only goes so far. If your injuries meet specific legal thresholds, you can hold the other driver responsible. Kentucky law lets you step outside the no-fault system when:

  • Your medical bills exceed $1,000, or
  • You suffer a broken bone, permanent injury, disfigurement or death

Once your case qualifies, you can file a claim against the at-fault driver and ask for additional compensation, including pain and suffering or long-term medical costs.

Fault-based claims differ from no-fault benefits

No-fault benefits give you fast, limited coverage through your insurer. But when your needs exceed that limit, fault-based claims open the door to broader recovery. You can seek damages for pain, emotional distress, lost earning potential and more. Kentucky’s hybrid system starts you with no fault, but once your injuries cross the legal line, fault becomes the central factor.

Opting out of no-fault changes how claims are handled

Kentucky lets drivers reject PIP by signing a written waiver. If you opted out, you skipped no-fault coverage entirely and went straight into a fault-based system. You gave up the automatic $10,000 in PIP, but you gained the right to sue – and be sued – from day one. Some drivers make that trade on purpose and others don’t realize what they’ve lost until the bills start piling up.

Understanding the system helps you protect your rights

You can’t always prevent a crash, but you can understand how Kentucky’s system works after one happens. Whether you’re still using PIP or already building a fault-based claim, knowing when that shift occurs gives you more control. And if you’re unsure whether your injuries meet the threshold or if your policy limits your options, now might be the right time to talk to someone who knows how to handle these cases.